Lip Tar by Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics is my new favorite lippy. The texture is thin and light but covers like a lipstick. The colors can be worn alone, under a gloss, over a balm and mixes well with others. The most precise application comes from using a lip brush but I typically just use my ring finger. A little goes a long way so $14 for the tube is quite generous and the formula is 100% vegan to boot!
I purchased two middle of the road colors (Memento & Grandma) but for my next order I'll get a little more daring. Check out the full range of colors here.